When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Vintage Wagner Ware National #8 Cast Iron Skillet Star Molder Mark 9 7/8" Light
There’s cast iron… and then there’s Wagner cast iron. This #8 skillet hits that sweet spot collectors and cooks chase—exceptionally smooth, impressively light, and cast with the kind of precision that makes modern pans feel like they skipped leg day. Pick it up and you’ll immediately notice: thin, elegant sidewalls, fast heat response, and that glassy cooking surface Wagner was famous for. This isn’t just cookware—it’s early 20th-century American manufacturing showing off.
Maker & History
This skillet comes from Wagner Manufacturing Company of Sidney, Ohio—one of the “big three” golden-era American foundries alongside Griswold and Favorite.
Wagner built its reputation on:
- Precision casting (thinner, lighter, more refined than competitors)
- Machined cooking surfaces (nearly polished smooth from the factory)
- Consistency at scale (they were producing millions of pieces by the early 1900s)
The “National” line was a slightly more utilitarian branding used during Wagner’s peak production years—still high quality, just marketed a bit differently than their premium-marked pieces.
Precise Date
Based on the “Star Molder” mark and “National” branding, this skillet dates to circa 1915–1925 (aka she is over 100 years old and qualiifies for antique-status from a duty/tarrif perspective).
That puts it squarely in the era when:
- American foundries were at peak craftsmanship before cost-cutting crept in
- Skilled molders (hence the star mark) were individually recognized for their work
- Cast iron was still a precision industry, not just bulk production
Craftsmanship & Build
- Size: 9 7/8" diameter x 2" tall
- Weight: 3.8 lbs (notably light for a #8)
- Walls: Just slightly thicker than a U.S. nickel → exceptional thin casting
- Surface: Smooth, refined cooking surface typical of early Wagner
- Heat ring: Subtle and well-formed for stable stovetop use
This is exactly what collectors mean when they say “they don’t make them like this anymore.”
Modern pans often feel like armor plating—this feels like a precision instrument.
Condition
- Cleaned and seasoned with Crisco, ready for immediate use
- Nearly flat: only a faint tick—corrected with a single sheet of paper (a business card is too thick, which tells you how minor it is)
- No cracks, no structural issues
- Excellent overall integrity for a 100+ year-old working piece
Performance (why people actually hunt these)
- Heats faster than thicker modern cast iron
- Holds heat evenly thanks to fine casting
- Naturally nonstick surface improves with use
- Ideal for gas, electric, induction and oven use
This is one of those pieces where you pick it up and immediately get it—light, smooth, balanced, and clearly made by someone who took pride in their work a century ago. If you know cast iron, you already know… this is the kind you keep.
